Skip to content

Stephenie Meyer – Eclipse

October 22, 2007

106. Eclipse by Stephenie Meyer (2007)
Twilight Series, Book 3

Length: 640 pages

Genre: Young Adult; Urban fantasy

Started: 21 October 2007
Finished: 22 October 2007

Summary: Now that Edward and Bella are back together in the small town of Forks, there’s a tense stalemate between the vampiric Cullen family and the werewolves of the Quileute tribe – and more particularly, between Edward Cullen and Jacob Black, both of whom love Bella and will stop at nothing to win her. To add to the tension, there has been a spate of murders in nearby Seattle, and there is reason to believe the danger is centered on Bella – but can everyone put their melodrama away for long enough to keep themselves and the ones they love safe?

Review: First, the positives. Number one: DAMN these books are addictive. I had to force myself to put this down to go to sleep late last night, and I came home this afternoon, picked it up, and didn’t move (except to turn pages) until I’d finished it. This book also does a much better job than the previous two of balancing the angsty teenage melodrama with the action – instead being five hundred pages of whining followed by fifty of action, this book spread out the action and interspersed it with the angsty whining, which made it more tolerable, and probably accounts for most of this book’s improved rating compared to the other two.

Next, to the negatives. Far and away, the main thing that bugs me about these books (not this one in particular more than the others, but the whole series) is what a messed up model for love, relationships, sex, and romance they are providing for the legions of teenaged girls who are the target audience. Edward’s treated like this perfect, wonderful, self-sacrificing guy, when in reality he’s arrogant, selfish, stubborn, arrogant, manipulative, arrogant, emotionally stunted, and immature. The book holds up this idea of “literally can’t live without you here” as being an ideal, instead of a frightening level of codependecy and self-effacement, and, at least in the first half of the book, Edward and Bella’s relationship doesn’t just hover near the boundary of creepy, it actually leaps over the line into legitimately over-controlling and emotionally abusive. The “hostage” scene was played as maddening but maddeningly-charming, when in reality, isolating a partner from “non-approved” friends is a classic sign of abuse, and Bella writes it off as “just jealousy” and instantly forgives him as soon as she sees him – because he’s so dreamy. Is that really what we want teenaged girls to be absorbing as okay behavior? And let’s not even get me started on the issues these books have surrounding sex and sexual morality.

I don’t have nearly so many issues with Jacob – admittedly, he’s also immature and selfish, but at least he’s also honest about it… and I do, ultimately, agree with him that he’d be better for Bella in the long run. Actually, this book does a pretty good job of dealing with the reality of obsessive teenage relationships, it’s just that it so desperately wants us to believe that Bella’s choice is the right one, that it’s true love, when from the distance of a little maturity it just looks like hormones and overwrought teenage drama. 4 out of 5 stars.

Recommendation: I have so many issues with these books, but I can’t stop reading them, and if you’ve got through the first two, you can’t either. Better than the first two, and the compelling story makes it easier to overlook all of the melodramatic angst.

This Review on LibraryThing | This Book on LibraryThing | This Book on Amazon

5 Comments leave one →
  1. Bethany permalink
    June 23, 2008 12:33 pm

    OMG!!!!!! LOVED THE BOOKS!!!!! AHAHAHAHA! same as the message on L.A meyer’s thin, young writter lookin for a publisher to send a tastre to!! need help!

  2. Nicky permalink
    January 30, 2009 8:05 pm

    well written and very good points raised….I especially like that you admit they are addictive anyway, despite all its flaws, which makes the experience that much more annoying…what part of our psyche do these books tap into, despite all its flaws and disturbing messages to teenagers??????? I can’t figure it out…except maybe one thing. As a 30 something, there is one part of Edward’s character that is compelling and that is his dedication/loyalty to her, you know he will never leave her. Yes, it is surrounded by alot of disturbing qualities (e.g., possessiveness, arrogance etc) but still….a woman does wish that a man could be that loyal to her…to curb her insecurities about him leaving her.

  3. cherrycola1788 permalink
    February 10, 2009 10:31 am

    While I usually don’t comment on blogs, and usually agree with your tastes, I can’t really here. I read all four of those misbegotten things and I’m still regretting it. The story is addictive to some, I guess, but the entire thing was too overdone for me, from Meyer’s basic writing style (Harlequin romance dressed up for church) and her insistence on using words, characters, and ideas not her own as if they were toothpicks. She has a little talent, not a lot, but the sooner she gets away from the self-insertive romance novels and actually writes something that isn’t her fantasy (the only real fault I had with The Host is that Melanie was far too much like Bella, and that both of them smacked dangerously of Meyer), the more respectable of an author she will be.

  4. justbookreading permalink
    September 25, 2011 5:03 pm

    I’m absolutely sure I killed some brain cells with these books. :-)

  5. September 26, 2011 3:49 am

    I’m currently listening to the audio book of this at the moment and totally agree with you about how possessive and controlling Edward is. It’s not a relationship that should be seen as romantic, in fact Edward treats Bella more like his daughter (at the point that I am in the story), rather than a lover. Is this kind of relationship something that Stephenie Meyer wants to promote to her readers? To me, the level of possessiveness is unhealthy.

    Whilst I found the other books to be filled with sexual tension, I’m finding that ‘Eclipse’ is a bit creepy almost sinister.

    Great Review

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: